I was astonished at kasss mastery of both the issue and the writing as opposed to wilson. While many of these views are religious in origin, some of the questions raised by cloning are faced by secular perspectives as well. As science increasingly crosses borders, so do the implications of deeply personal health sciences. After reading the viewpoints, i cannot say i have a firm stance in either direction. The ethical implications of human cloning department of government,harvard university,1875 cambridge street,cambridge,ma,028. Although much of the ethical discussion related to human cloning has focused on. Researchers and ethicists, including the scottish scientist who successfully cloned an adult. Wilson acknowledges the philosophical and theological issues, but openmindedly sees no problem with clones being provided for married 2parent families. The legal and ethical issues of cloning that make it. Two religion panelists, suzanne holland and laurie zoloth, are co editors of the human embryonic stem cell debate. The ethics of cloning julian savulescu enacted laws banning cloning, and several international declara tions prohibit it figure 1. Like most people, i instinctively recoil from the idea of cloning human beings.
The ethics of human cloning bruce glassman, vice president bonnie szumski, publisher helen cothran, managing editor john woodward, book editor detroit new york san francisco san diego new haven, conn. Cloning itself is not new, but as the science of cloning continues to advanceand as human cloning thus inches closer to realitywe are compelled to consider its implications for society. Wilson, the preeminent political scientist to whom four u. In 1966 lederberg wrote a remarkable article in the american naturalist detailing the eugenic advantages of human cloning and other forms of genetic engineering, and the following year he devoted a. However, the famous case of dolly the sheep demonstrates human cloning to be a possible reality. Waterville, maine london munich ai ethicshuman cloning int 7904 3. Human cloning is a lucid, substantive guide to this contentious and potentially revolutionary issue. Sep 29, 2017 though animal and reproductive cloning are a concern for some religious sects, today the debate is mostly centered on the cloning of human embryonic stem cells, which are used for treatment and research of diseases. However, the birth of dolly lamb 6ll3 in 1997 not only brought the subject to the public domain but it also led to furious debates as regards the morality or otherwise of the application of such a techbique to humans. Human cloning is the process of taking the genetic sequence from a human being, who is or once was alive, and transferring it into an embryo. Kevles cloning humans may be impossible philip cohen all human cloning is immoral.
The science of human cloning is not the primary concern of never let me go, and ishiguro takes artistic license with some of the details of how humans are cloned in his novel. All three panelists commended the decision of the state advisory committee to deal separately with the issues of human cloning and stem cell research. A dialogue on state regulation was convened october 12, 2001, by the markkula center for applied ethics at santa clara university. At the time this book was written no one had yet claimed to have cloned a human being and the debate was raging, should science even try. Of the technologies discussed in the book, the idea of human cloning was the most evocative of creative science fiction shows and seemingly improbable in our lifetimes. Miller, managing editor william dudley, book editor ethics of human cloning all 21104 1. Two separate nationallevel reports on human cloning nbac, 1997.
Human cloning moral and ethical aspects united states. From this collection, readers will gain a clearer picture of the history of cloning in agriculture and. Wilson, the preeminent political scientist to whom four united states presidents have turned for advice on crime, drug abuse, education, and other crises in american life, explore the ethics of human. An ethical inquiry 2002, by presidents council on bioethics u. Wilson and kass talked about their book, the ethics of human cloning, which is about the ethical debate over human cloning. The ethics of human cloning american enterprise institute aei. An approach to the ethics of cloning humans via an examination of the ethical issues pertaining to the use of any tool. In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice and possibilities of cloning, especially human cloning. The ethics of human cloning john woodward, book editor.
Questia read the fulltext online edition of the ethics of human cloning 1998. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research markkula. Many of the pros and cons that are being discussed today were being discussed 4 years ago when this book was written, shortly after dolly, the cloned sheep was born. Hefley suggested that on a scale of one to ten, scientists are at about a 9. In this concise volume, experts on all sides of the debate make arguments for why we should either pursue, regulate, or ban the cloning of human beings. This essay is based on a public lecture delivered at an international conference on cloning organized. Recent events in britain and the united states have shown that human cloning, as well as cloning animals, raises important ethical questions. List of books and articles about cloning online research. Cloning raises ethical questions about life, human limits and love by lefevere, patricia national catholic reporter, vol.
Wilson family structure, not the method of reproduction, is what matters. At issue series the ethics of human cloning hardcover. At issue series the ethics of human cloning hardcover edition. Ethics and cloning british medical bulletin oxford academic. Full text full text is available as a scanned copy of the original print version. Ever since the advent of cloning, there have been arguments for and against this process. Ui press edited by barbara mackinnon human cloning.
This book explores the opposing viewpoints concerning the ethics of human cloning. This work attempts to critically examine most of the arguments profferred. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The national academy of sciences, while supporting 2001 such socalled therapeutic or research cloning, has opposed 2002 the cloning of humans for reproductive purposes, deeming it unsafe, but many ethicists, religious and political leaders, and others have called for banning human cloning for any purpose. Human cloning can refer to human reproductive cloning, where the embryo is transferred to a human womb and brought to term, whereas human nonreproductive cloning is the creation of an embryo that.
Indeed, it is the bioethicists, not the scientists, who are now the most articulate defenders of human cloning. Is human cloning a science fiction nightmare come true. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Jan 01, 2004 this book explores the opposing viewpoints concerning the ethics of human cloning. Nevertheless, many of his questions about the ethics of human cloning are ones that have been raised and debated in real life. The ethical implications of human clones have been much alluded to, but have seldom been examined with any rigour. The ethics of human reproductive cloning sciencedirect. The ethics of human cloning movies the new york times. A fundamental argument is that cloning is ethically wrong and various religious groups have rejected it saying that cloning is equivalent to playing god. It features arguments for and against from multiple viewpoints and concerning multiple facets of the cloning process and options. Or is it a practical avenue toward beneficial new medical treatments and techniques. It is a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization of research scholars from multiple disciplines, including philosophy, law, political science, and education. Explores such issues regarding cloning as the identity of clones, the purpose of cloning, political debate, and religious arguments from a variety of viewpoints.
No other science has advanced more dramatically during the past several decades or yielded so many palpable improvements in human welfare. In 2005, the united nations adopted a declaration on human cloning, which calls for a universal ban on human cloning. Cloning is where a cell is taken from an animal or human and the nucleus is combined with an unfertilised egg from which the nucleus has been removed, in order to create an egg which starts to divide to create if it survives implantation in the womb an identical twin of the animal or human from which the cell was taken. Once merely a theme for science fiction writers, the possibility of cloning human beings now joins a growing list of concerns wherein technology outstrips.
Scientists have cloned animals since the late 19th century, but the crucial step for ethics was the cloning of the first mammal by somatic cell nuclear transfer in 1997. Wilsons essays simply dont compare in quality to the time and thought that obviously went into kasss. Glenn mcgee is associate director for education at the cen ter for bioethics at the university of pennsylvania school of medicines center for bioethics, as well as assistant profes sor of bioethics in the departments of philosophy, history, and sociology. Perspectives on human cloning are theoretical, as human therapeutic and reproductive cloning are not. Some see it as a reproductive right or believe the technology will lead to cures for a host of diseases. The ethics of human cloning hardcover june, 1998 by leon kass author. Read the fulltext online edition of the ethics of human cloning 1998.
Founded in 1969, the hastings center is the worlds first bioethics research institute. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research california cloning. Nov 20, 2007 in europe, though, genetically modified crops are taboo. The ethics of human cloning by wilson, james q kass. This work attempts to critically examine most of the arguments profferred both for and against human cloning. Ethics and reproductive technology traversing tradition. The clone embryo is allowed to grow, and is then placed into a uterus where it grows until it. This suggested that scientists could also clone, and possibly enhance, human beings. The ethics of human reproductive cloning carson strong is professor in the department of human values and ethics, university of tennessee college of medicine, usa. Nas, 2002 concluded that attempts to clone a human being would be unethical at this time due to safety concerns and the likelihood of harm to those involved. An undercover journey into the heart of madness undark the moment her illness was deemed neurological, as in physical, in the body, real, rather than psychiatric, in the mind and therefore somehow less real, the quality of her care drastically improved, cahalan writes in her new book. Wilson talked about their book, the ethics of human cloning, published by aei press. The catholic church, in particular, has voiced strong opposition against cloning.
The book length exchange between these two men is available free from tae as part of a special promotion. Never let me go never let me go and the ethics of human. Kass, the noted teacher, scientist, and humanist, and james q. Miller, managing editor william dudley, book editor ethics of human cloning. The ethics of human cloning today biological science is rising on a wall of worry.
Buy the ethics of human cloning by leon r kass, james k wilson online at alibris. Jun 06, 2012 the ethics of human cloning today biological science is rising on a wall of worry. Cloning human embryos for research has been legally supported in england and several other countries, but it is banned in more than a dozen. Kass, the noted teacher, scientist, humanist, and chairman of the presidents council on bioethics, and james q. Publication date 1998 topics human cloning moral and ethical aspects, human reproductive technology moral and ethical aspects. The ethics of human cloning by leon r kass, james k wilson. In this paper i will consider the ethics of cloning as it occurs in kazuo ishiguros dystopian novel never let me go from the standpoint of a number of moral theories consequentialism, natural law theory, kantian moral theory, rights based theory, and virtue ethics. Public health and safety subcommittee members held a hearing about the science and ethics of clone. About book this slim volume is the best introduction to the ethical debate over human cloning now available, as two of americas most respected public intellectuals tangle over the question of whether its a good idea to let people make genetic duplicates of themselves. Bender, publisher bruno leone, executive editor bonnie szumski, editorial director stuart b. This paper examines the possible uses and abuses of human cloning and draws out. Its purpose was to bring together experts from the fields of science, religion, ethics, and law to discuss how the state of california should. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research.
Both essays are very engaging and cover many angles. Moral theories and cloning in kazuo ishiguros never let me go. Human cloning requires us to think about the nature of a human embryo, the moral status of the human embryo, what is required by respect for human embryos, and whether the distinction between spare embryos that is, those left over from in vitro. Would the use of human cloning violate important moral rights. As human cloning becomes even more probable, human cloning sets out to address the scientific, ethical, and public policy questions that will need to be addressed long before it becomes a reality. Wilsons essay the paradox of cloning the new republic, june 2, 1997, attacks the issue from another angle. Although the vast majority of books that have lexile measures did not change, a small subset of books required updated lexile measures.
How morality and ethics factor in if a random individual were asked twenty years ago if heshe believed that science could clone an animal, most would have given a weird look and responded, are you kidding me. Human cloning may be moving from the realm of science fiction to reality. Although movies and books sometimes make it seem like human cloning would only lead to an army of clones taking over the world and destroying mankind, there must be a scientific reason that this topic is being researched. San diego, california the ethics of human cloning david l. In their valuable book, human cloning playing god or scientific progress. Ethics and cloning british medical bulletin oxford. Here is a discussion about the ethical issues that have arisen concerned with cloning humans. Get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 206k, or click on a page image below to browse page by page. The national academy of sciences, while supporting 2001 such socalled therapeutic or research cloning, has opposed 2002 the cloning of humans for reproductive purposes, deeming it unsafe, but many ethicists, religious and political leaders, and others have called for banning human cloning. Many products and services offer lexile measures for their books and reading materials. Many countries or jurisdictions have legally banned human cloning or are in the process of doing so. In some countries, including france and singapore, reproductive cloning of humans is a criminal offence.
1287 95 1490 1533 1116 1035 448 1414 913 219 246 51 1225 479 1287 573 496 1543 828 443 569 844 254 1101 1246 1188 473 442 1496 1417 886 146